You are reading

Queens DA Files Motion to Overturn 1995 Robbery Conviction, Says Former Prosecutor Adopted Racist Approach in Jury Selection

Queens DA Melinda Katz (Photo: Instagram @queensdakatz)

Oct. 22, 2021 By Christian Murray

Queens District Attorney Melinda Katz announced Tuesday that her office filed a motion to overturn a 1995 conviction of a man found guilty of robbery.

Katz filed the motion after her Conviction Integrity Unit discovered that the Assistant District Attorney at the time tainted the jury pool by improperly excluding certain minorities and women from jury service in violation of a U.S. Supreme Court ruling.

Honorable Michelle Johnson, in response to the motion, vacated the conviction and dismissed the indictment of Lawrence Scott who was found guilty at trial for robbing a cab driver.

The CIU discovered the discriminatory practice after it was made aware in 2020 that Christopher McGrath, a former Assistant District Attorney, had adopted the discriminatory approach with other cases.

Katz’ office dismissed two 1996 convictions after discovering McGrath had expressly provided discriminatory guidance in the selection of the jury.  One of the convictions was for a double murder and another for the shooting of a police office. Katz said at the time the defendants would be retried.

The CIU then reviewed all jury trials conducted by McGrath—who resigned in 1997—to see whether he improperly excluded certain minorities and women from jury service in other cases.

“Late last year, we discovered two 1996 convictions had been tainted by evidence of discrimination in jury selection. At that, time, we made a commitment to review other cases and take appropriate action,” Katz said in a statement Tuesday. “Today’s motion to vacate this defendant’s conviction reaffirms my administration’s determination to reject any form of discrimination.”

Scott was convicted for robbing a cab driver in which he held a hard object to the victim’s neck while an apprehended accomplice stole the victim’s wallet. Scott was captured because he dropped his own wallet while fleeing the scene.

He was sentenced to five to ten years in prison.

Scott has long completed his sentence but is presently incarcerated on a different robbery, and counsel has been appointed to assess the impact of the reversal of this prior conviction on his current sentence.

The CIU has now vacated 10 convictions since it was formed by Katz after she took office in 2020.

email the author: news@queenspost.com
No comments yet

Leave a Comment
Reply to this Comment

All comments are subject to moderation before being posted.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Recent News

Unwind after hours at these cozy Queens cafes

Jul. 25, 2025 By Jessica Militello

Forget the bars and crowded clubs — Queens is brimming with charming cafes that keep their doors open well past sunset, offering a perfect alternative for those who want to meet up for a late-night hangout without the alcohol. From authentic Yemeni coffee houses to bakeries with outdoor garden patios, check out these Queens cafes for your next late-night catch-up with friends, or for a cozy date night plan.

Cool off this summer with margaritas in Queens

Jul. 25, 2025 By Paulina Albarracin

The summer season ushers in outdoor adventures, extended daylight hours and sweltering heat, making it the perfect time to kick back at a local restaurant or bar and order a refreshing margarita. Sipping on this tequila-infused cocktail is one of the best ways to beat the heat and revel with margarita connoisseurs in your neighborhood.

A slice of legacy: Carlo’s Pizzeria keeps Sicilian tradition alive in Middle Village

Jul. 18, 2025 By Christy Hinko

On Metropolitan Avenue, between 74th and 75th streets in Middle Village, Carlo’s Pizzeria isn’t just a place to grab a slice — it’s a place where history is folded into every piece of dough, sauce and cheese. The beloved neighborhood pizzeria has been serving Queens for nearly 60 years, now led by third-generation owner Anthony Caruana, who proudly carries forward the dream his grandfather brought from Sicily.