You are reading

Martha’s Country Bakery in Forest Hills Shut Down by the Health Dept., Prompts Social Media Outcry

Martha’s Country Bakery in Forest Hills, pictured, was shut down by the Health Dept. Monday (Photos Provided to Queens Post)

Aug. 25, 2021 By Christian Murray

A Forest Hills bakery known for its long lines and popular pastries has been closed by the Health Dept.—prompting an avalanche of criticism from residents.

Martha’s County Bakery on Austin Street, which is part of a Queens-based bakery chain, was shut down by the Health Dept. on Monday, according to city records. The other Martha’s locations—in Astoria, Bayside and Williamsburg—remain open.

The Austin Street establishment was hit with a number of violations, with an inspector finding flies, contaminated surfaces and employees wearing unclean garments. Patch was first to report the story.

Signage posted Monday by the DOH at Martha’s Country Bakery at 70-28 Austin St. (Photo provided to Queens Post)

A Forest Hills resident posted a picture to a popular Facebook group of a Dept. of Health notice saying that Martha’s had been ordered “Closed.”

The resident also posted a photo put up by the owners that claimed the store had been shuttered stemming from plumbing issues.

“Due to plumbing issues and construction work we will be closed until further notice,” the notice read.

The abrupt closure has led to flurry of Facebook comments since Monday. By Wednesday afternoon, more than 230 comments had been posted.

“This place was so dirty the last time I went there, I am surprised the health department didn’t close it sooner,” one commenter said.

Another said: “It must have been really bad for the health department to close them.”

Several residents criticized the bakery for making it appear that the closure was construction related.  “That “plumbing issue” letter is bulls$$t,” one person wrote. Another said: “It has nothing to do with construction it was a fly infestation!!”

Signage posted this week by the owners of Martha’s Country Bakery at 70-28 Austin St. (Photo provided to Queens Post)

But the popular bakery does have fans.

“Glad it’s only temporary. I need my caramel mousse cake,” wrote one person.

“NOOOOOOOO, how will I survive without my weekly carrot cake!” read another comment.

“So sad! I love their pastries.”

The bakery racked up a whopping 66 points. The DOH assigns points based on each infringement and the level risk it presents. For instance, critical violations carry a minimum of 5 points each.

An eatery scores an A grade when it scores between 0-13 points; a B when it is between 14-27; and a C for 28 or more.

The Health Dept., however, typically only closes a venue down when a violation cannot be corrected at the time of inspection.

Martha’s DOH Violations

1)            Food not protected from potential source of contamination during storage, preparation, trans                 portation, display or service.
2)            Personal cleanliness inadequate. Outer garment soiled with possible contaminant. Effective                   hair restraint not worn in an area where food is prepared.
3)            Wiping cloths soiled or not stored in sanitizing solution.
4)            Hot food item not held at or above 140º F.
5)            Food contact surface not properly washed, rinsed and sanitized after each use and following                 any activity when contamination may have occurred.
6)            Filth flies or food/refuse/sewage-associated (FRSA) flies present in facility’s food and/or non-                 food areas. Filth flies include house flies, little house flies, blow flies,
bottle flies and flesh flies. Food/refuse/sewage-associated flies include fruit flies, drain flies                     and Phorid flies.
7)            Facility not vermin proof. Harborage or conditions conducive to attracting vermin to the                            premises and/or allowing vermin to exist.
8)            Non-food contact surface improperly constructed. Unacceptable material used. Non-food con                 tact surface or equipment improperly maintained and/or not properly sealed, raised,
spaced or movable to allow accessibility for cleaning on all sides, above and underneath the                 unit.

email the author: [email protected]


Click for Comments 

What a shame (on them). This would normally be my go-to bakery, but I thank the health dept. for not allowing them to subject their loyal patrons to unsanitary conditions and possible illness, especially at a time when we should be most conscious of cleanliness. Gross.


How gross!!!! Can’t believe they disrespect their customers’ health to this extend. Won’t be going there anytime soon.

Sara Ross

I feel bad for the people that work there. I know the manager doesn’t give a dam about the employees. She’ll keep the place open after midnight as long as people go there. No bakery needs to be open after 10:00! As long as you’re open, people will show up. She doesn’t care that the employees have to leave at 1:00 a,m. and travel home, especially with the homeless that hang out on Austin Street and Continental Avenue. I’ve lived in FH for many years and have only seen this the last couple of years (before Covid). The precinct isn’t far from there – why don’t they do something?


May be they will come to their senses and bring the prices down. But honestly, the health dept should close every Chinese restaurant for roaches, mice and other crap running around. It’s not fare.

Jeffrey A Schnepf

I had purchased a pie from them for my friend who had just finished cancer chemo. It had mold on it. I brought it back. I got a refund but no apology.


The place seemed busy to me I went in once looking for sugarfree items nothing I should eat

Cynthia andrews

Thank goodness for the other locations. I love the williamsburgh marthas – friendly and clean!!


I love that bakery I always found clean good employees I am shocked to here them close due to cleanliness.


It’s not as unusual as people think. Having worked with restaurants they all try hard to keep out insects and rodents. Especially when they need to use a basement.

It seems the cakes and such come from a common kitchen someplace else so probably the cakes are all fine.. as long as they stored carefully.. if you ride the subway you see what is lurking all around us.. I am sure once they reopen all will be fine

Bobbie Thompson

I found it very overpriced and my own cupcakes taste better from a mix..sorry , but some of their cakes were overly sweet .went in only a few times ..won’t miss it.

Simone Caillet

Thank God the DOH caught the problem on time, otherwise the living bacteria in there could have killed us. I will never go back there again.


Those supposedly delicious desserts, are expensive overpriced dead flies that you are eating! Please think twice before visiting Martha’s again. Even if they do reopen. YUCK!


Martha’s is disgusting! With the outlandish prices they charge for extremely small portions the least they can do is keep the place clean. The numerous health violations pose a risk to the people that patronage the establishment. It’s a shame they are not more concerned about cleanliness and the health of their customers.


Leave a Comment
Reply to this Comment

All comments are subject to moderation before being posted.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Recent News

Urgent manhunt underway for ‘animal’ who allegedly raped a 13-year-old girl in Flushing park on Thursday: NYPD

The NYPD announced a $10,000 reward is being offered for information that leads to the arrest of a Hispanic man who allegedly raped a 13-year-old girl in a wooded area of Kissena Corridor Park on Thursday afternoon.

More than sixty investigators were at the crime scene late into the night. During a press briefing by NYPD brass on Friday, Chief of Department Jeffrey Maddrey said that the manhunt was expanded city-wide and that the department would spare no expense until the suspect was apprehended.

Op-ed: Protecting Forest Hills Stadium

Jun. 14, 2024 By Thomas Grech

After more than a decade since its rebirth, it is unfathomable to consider Forest Hills without our venerable 101-year-old Forest Hills Stadium. The iconic venue is an asset to our community in so many ways – from creating jobs, to supporting local organizations, to providing invaluable links to our community’s rich history. Amazingly, a small band of unrealists who fail to understand that communities are constructed on the mutual grace and respect of our neighbors, want to shut down Forest Hills Stadium for good.

Op-ed: Congestion pricing would do much more harm than good for New Yorkers

Jun. 11, 2024 By Assemblymember David I. Weprin

Like many residents throughout the five boroughs and across the New York Metro Area, I was pleasantly surprised by Governor Kathy Hochul’s decision to “indefinitely pause” the implementation of Congestion Pricing. Rather than seeing this as a cynical calculation, as some have alleged, I see the Governor’s decision as a deeply pragmatic response to the crescendo of public concerns that I and many others have raised for years. As the countdown to the June 30 implementation date neared, everyday New Yorkers did what we do best: we spoke up for ourselves and said we won’t accept a bad deal! I applaud Governor Hochul for having the courage not just to listen to us but to take a tough stand against this misguided policy.